SharpeX Logo & Home button

Historic Housing Affordability Crisis: Tackling Deterioration

The U.S. Housing Market's Affordability Crisis: A Perfect Storm Brewing

Photography of a crossroads in a rural area with a cloudy sky and a house in the distance

In a startling turn of events, the American dream of homeownership has taken a severe hit, plunging the nation into an unprecedented housing affordability crisis. The confluence of skyrocketing home prices and soaring mortgage rates has created a perfect storm, leaving potential buyers grappling with the harsh realities of an increasingly unaffordable market.

The numbers paint a grim picture: Since March 2020, home prices have surged a staggering 44%, while mortgage rates have skyrocketed from a mere 3% to a dizzying 8%. This dramatic shift has translated into the fastest-ever deterioration in housing affordability, with monthly payments on the median-priced home escalating by a whopping 27% year-over-year – a jaw-dropping 120% increase from the mortgage rate lows of just 2.5 years ago.

July 2023 stood out as the least affordable month for U.S. housing this century, and with the recent surge in mortgage rates, the readings for August, September, and October are expected to be even worse. Improving affordability will require a delicate balance of rising incomes, declining home prices, or lower mortgage rates, with mortgage rates offering the most potential for short-term impact.

The ripple effects of this affordability crisis are already being felt across the housing market. Homeowners, reluctant to sell and face the daunting prospect of purchasing a new home at exorbitant prices, have contributed to a lack of turnover in the market. While the market still sees some activity from deaths, divorces, and first-time buyers, the churn of homeowners trading up or down has been notably absent, according to the ResiClub CEO.

Affordability challenges have prompted a slowdown in house price growth, with mortgage rates continuing to surge in April 2024, driving a 1.5% decline in affordability compared to March and a 9% decrease year-over-year. While house prices have fallen from their peaks in over a third of the top 50 markets, the significant price gains made during the pandemic remain a formidable obstacle.

As the housing market navigates these turbulent waters, affordability is expected to continue to be a drag until house-buying power recovers or prices cool further. A "higher-for-longer" mortgage rate environment is anticipated to prolong the cooling trend for house prices, though price declines are unlikely to fully offset the pandemic-era gains.

In this climate of uncertainty, potential homebuyers find themselves at a crossroads, forced to grapple with the harsh realities of an increasingly unaffordable market. The road ahead is paved with challenges, but also glimmers of hope, as the market seeks to find its equilibrium in the face of this perfect storm.